The Journal · Family
Capability Cannot Be Inherited
Wealthy parents can pass on almost anything except the competence that comes from facing real stakes, and the instinct to protect children from those stakes is where the difficulty begins.
A family can transfer a portfolio in an afternoon. It cannot transfer the ability to manage one, or the steadiness to face a setback, or the quiet confidence of someone who knows they can earn their own way. Those qualities are not assets that sit somewhere waiting to be handed over. They are built, slowly, by the person who will have them, through experiences in which something real was at stake. This is the central difficulty of raising children with money. Wealth's great gift is that it removes stakes. Capability is what grows when stakes are present. The work of a wealthy parent is to hold both truths at once.
An old worry, with some evidence
The concern is not new. In 1889 Andrew Carnegie, then one of the richest men in the world, argued in the North American Review that leaving great fortunes to children was usually a mistake. "Observation teaches that, generally speaking, it is not well for the children that they should be so burdened," he wrote, and he suspected that "it is not the welfare of the children, but family pride, which inspires these enormous legacies." He put it most memorably in the voice of the thoughtful parent: "I would as soon leave to my son a curse as the almighty dollar."
A century later three economists tested a narrow version of his claim. Using tax-return data on people before and after they received inheritances, Holtz-Eakin, Joulfaian and Rosen reported in 1993 that their results were "consistent with Andrew Carnegie's century-old assertion that large inheritances decrease a person's labor force participation". For example, a single person who received an inheritance of over $150,000 was roughly four times more likely to leave the labour force than one who received less than $25,000.
It is important not to over-read this. Leaving paid work is not the same as a wasted life; some heirs leave jobs to raise families, build something of their own or devote themselves to public service. The study measures behaviour, not character or happiness. What it does show is that large sums of unearned money change what people choose to do, which is exactly what one would expect. The question for parents is not whether wealth will change their children's choices. It will. The question is whether the children will still have reasons, and the ability, to choose demanding things.
Two ways to fail
The popular image of the spoiled heir suggests that the main risk is indulgence: too much given, too little asked. The research on affluent young people points to something more complicated.
Since the mid-1990s, the psychologist Suniya Luthar and colleagues have studied adolescents in upper-middle-class American communities, a group not usually thought of as at risk. In a 2013 review in Development and Psychopathology, Luthar, Barkin and Crossman summarised findings that these young people showed higher rates than normative samples of substance use and of both internalising and externalising problems. In two East Coast samples, rates of being drunk in the past month were about twice those in national norms. These were communities defined by comfortable incomes rather than great fortunes, and the findings concern American schools, so they should not be transplanted carelessly to every wealthy family everywhere. But the patterns the authors describe are instructive.
On substance use, the review reports that the single most robust predictor was low parental containment: teenagers who expected few consequences from their parents were among the heaviest users. Perceived parental criticism showed stronger links with a range of adjustment measures than positive family qualities such as strong attachment did. And in one suburban sample, which showed marked elevations in symptoms, young people also reported relatively low closeness to their parents. Looking to remedies, the authors recall the conclusion of Emmy Werner's classic research on resilience, that it "stems foremost from a strong relationship with a caring adult, within or outside the family."
Read together, these findings suggest two failure modes rather than one. The first is the familiar one: a childhood without limits or consequences, in which nothing is ever really at stake. The second is less often discussed: a childhood of relentless expectation, in which children are pushed to perform while feeling that their worth depends on the result and that the adults around them are, in some important sense, absent. Both have something in common. In neither case is the child the author of their own effort. In the first, effort is unnecessary. In the second, it belongs to someone else.
Agency needs real stakes
If capability cannot be given, what can parents give? A useful frame comes from self-determination theory, one of the more established bodies of research on motivation. Ryan and Deci, in a widely cited 2000 paper in American Psychologist, proposed that people have three basic psychological needs, for competence, autonomy and relatedness, and that conditions which support these needs foster self-motivation and healthy development. The theory is general, not a guide to wealthy families, but its three terms map closely onto the problem.
Competence comes from doing things that are genuinely difficult and succeeding, or failing and trying again. Autonomy comes from making choices that are one's own and living with the results. Relatedness comes from being connected to people who care regardless of the outcome. Wealth, handled without thought, can undermine the first two while doing nothing for the third. When every problem can be solved by a payment, a child has little opportunity to become competent at solving it. When every important decision is made by parents, trustees or advisers, a child has little opportunity to become autonomous.
The difficulty is that stakes have to be real to work. Children are acute observers of their own circumstances, and an allowance that is "tight" in a household where everything else is effortless teaches very little except that adults enjoy rules. Manufactured scarcity is not the same as responsibility. What seems to matter more is that children are given genuine domains of their own: work they are actually relied upon to do, money they actually control and can actually lose, commitments that others depend on. The consequences of failure in those domains should be real but survivable. A teenager who mismanages a modest sum and has to live with the result has learned something that no lecture on financial literacy can teach. A young adult who is rescued from every misstep has learned something too, which is that their choices do not matter.
None of this amounts to a method. Families differ in culture, in the size and form of their wealth, and in their children's temperaments. But the underlying principle is consistent: capability is grown in conditions where a person's own effort makes a difference, and parents with resources must work harder than others to preserve those conditions, because their resources tend to remove them.
Saying it out loud
Many wealthy families avoid discussing money with their children, often from good motives: a wish not to burden them, a fear of entitlement, a sense that the subject is vulgar. Silence, however, does not leave children without views about money. It leaves them to form views from what they observe, which is often a partial and misleading picture. A child who sees comfort without understanding where it came from, what it requires or what it is for may conclude that it is simply the natural state of things.
Talking openly does not mean announcing a number to a ten-year-old. It means treating money as a subject the family can discuss: how it was made, what it has cost, what the family believes it is for, what it will and will not be used to do. These conversations can grow with the child. They can also make room for disagreement, because adult heirs who have never been allowed to question the family's choices are poorly prepared to make their own.
Here family stories carry unusual weight. Duke, Lazarus and Fivush, in a 2008 study of children and adolescents, found that knowledge of family history was significantly correlated with an internal locus of control, higher self-esteem, better family functioning and lower anxiety, among other measures. The finding is correlational, and it would be naive to think that memorising facts about grandparents produces resilient children. More plausibly, families in which history is known are families in which people talk to one another, across generations, about things that matter. For wealthy families the content of those stories is important. A story in which the fortune arrived through genius and good luck teaches one thing. A story that includes the years of struggle, the mistakes, the near-failures and the values that held the family together through them teaches another: that the family's position was made by people who faced real difficulty, and that the children may face it too.
The best inheritance, in this view, is not a fortune protected from its heirs, nor heirs protected from their fortune. It is children who have been allowed enough difficulty to become capable, enough closeness to feel secure, and enough honesty to understand what they are inheriting and why.
Sources
- Andrew Carnegie, "Wealth", North American Review 148(391), 1889. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_North_American_Review/Volume_148/Issue_391/Wealth
- Holtz-Eakin, Joulfaian & Rosen, "The Carnegie Conjecture: Some Empirical Evidence", Quarterly Journal of Economics 108(2), 1993. https://econpapers.repec.org/RePEc:nbr:nberwo:4118
- Luthar, Barkin & Crossman, "'I can, therefore I must': Fragility in the upper-middle classes", Development and Psychopathology 25(4 Pt 2), 2013. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4215566
- Ryan & Deci, "Self-Determination Theory and the Facilitation of Intrinsic Motivation, Social Development, and Well-Being", American Psychologist 55(1), 2000. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.55.1.68
- Duke, Lazarus & Fivush, "Knowledge of family history as a clinically useful index of psychological well-being and prognosis: A brief report", Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training 45, 2008. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22122420
Senvell Journal essays are original analysis. They are not financial, legal, tax or investment advice.